Entertaining
I enjoyed the game, but I look at things for what they are, not what I think they ought to be, and for what this is, it was entertaining. There was a mystery to solve; you had to put pieces together; I followed the story and it led me to the solution. The only complaints I have is having to interview everyone about a particular person before you can accuse, though it does say that in the instructions; and the word search game did get a little monotonous. Also, I didnt catch what the doves meant.
I do have suggestions to make the game more rich:
I agree it would be cool to be able to replay and have a different killer each time. Though that would require much more work to create six more gameplaying experiences, complete with artwork, backstory and dialogue. It may not be feasible in this format or package, but I do think you have the opportunity here with a strong idea and characters.
Adding two or three different mini-games to earn coffee would be great to rotate through.
I am considering buying the next episode, which I rarely do with such mystery games.
Thanks
Steady Red Ranger about
Who Is The Killer (Episode One)